Ashley Young lynched for diving, so why not Didier Drogba?

Look at that for technique. Arched back, pained expression, two feet off the ground. 9.5 for the effort, Didier.

Diving is not something that I enjoy seeing, no matter what team I am watching or who is doing it. It is a mugs game. No fan of real football wants to see simulation on the pitch and it is one of the most aggravating aspects of the game that will, unfortunately, never cease to exist.

Ashley Young has been in the headlines for the wrong reasons recently with his controversially extrovert falls in the penalty area that has won United two penalties early on against QPR and Aston Villa.

The penalty incident recently against Aston Villa

As an individual, Ashley has won the most penalties in the Premier League (nine) since the 2009/10 season and with his dramatic throwbacks, it is not hard to see why. The only thing Ashley has to do is tumble naturally if he is thrown off balance with a stray foot or a mistimed tackle and the same outcome may well happen, just without the lynch mob jumping on his case. Against Aston Villa, there was contact. Minimal it may have been, but there was contact. He just made an absolute meal out of it.

On the back of the London Evening Standard today, SAF rightly points out the inconsistencies in the treatment of diving in relation to the recent antics of Ashley Young.

He has spoken with the former Villa play maker in an attempt to make him realise that things run a little bit differently when you are at United. He has drummed it out of Nani and Ronaldo in the past so if anybody can do it, it is SAF.

“I’ve had a word with Ashley. He understands where we come from and hopefully makes a difference.”

When it comes to diving, however, there are few better ambassadors than Didier Drogba. SAF pointed that out in a not so discreet manner later in the interview.

“I’ve watched the last few games and it was absolutely ridiculous. Players diving and rolling about. Nothing approaching what Young is accused of and the way the press have reacted is because it’s Manchester United. Absolutely no doubt  about that. You saw it the other night in the Chelsea game. I think we are in an age when you almost expect it now.”

Against Barcelona, he was at his absolute best. From feigned bollock injuries to excruciating tackles (see above), he managed to hold up the play for a total of six minutes and 30 seconds against Barcelona. Yet, what is the response?

The Daily Mail

Praise. Magnificent performance from Didier. Excellent all round show of what a football player can do to stop Barcelona. The Daily Mail even ran the caption “He spent most of the game diving and play-acting…” but ignored it in the grand scheme of things.

This would never happen were it United against Barcelona and Rooney had done the same thing. Especially at a time when diving is on the tip of every football pundit’s tongue, this is just the grossest of contradictions.

Had it not been against Barcelona, it may have been a different story. “Beat them at their own game”, people cry. Fair point, nobody gets under my skin more than scheming Sergio Busquets and his peeping Tom aspects from the game against Inter Milan. However, Jose Mourinho managed to beat Barcelona without cheating even after he was down to ten men, so why can’t anybody else?

Drogba plays peek-a-boo against Napoli after seeing Busquets do it against Inter Milan

The fact is that if Ashley Young was still an Aston Villa player and had won the penalty against another team, we would have forgotten about it by now. However, as it is United, it is still in the spotlight. All I call for is consistency. Drogba was downright dirty against Barcelona with his almost romantic relationship with the grass, such was their time spent together, but got praised for his actions.

If diving is something that is ever going to be cut out of football, then the approach to it must the same, no matter what the context is. Holding some players up for it whilst letters others slide is going to do nothing but encourage others to do it more, safe in the knowledge that may well get away with it.

Side note – here are a collection of other Tom Daley dives from this season. Side, side note – All of them are from Liverpool.

Andy Carroll vs Newcastle

Luis Suarez vs City. He tries to turn a foul into an injury.

Luis Suarez vs QPR. He won a free kick.

Luis Suarez vs Blackburn. He trips himself up, and wins a free kick for it.


4 Responses to Ashley Young lynched for diving, so why not Didier Drogba?

  1. patto1992 says:

    The difference is Ashley Young has effectively ended any contest of a football match, he got Shaun Derry sent off, killed the game. Yes Drogba was play acting and cheating but did he get anyone deliberately sent off no. The QPR fans and Villa fans to an extent have wasted their money as soon as the penalties are given and that is not right. If Ashley Young scores a brilliant goal then they will say fair enough but he didn’t and their fans deserve to be treated with respect from professionals. I think the main point should have been that it is the fans that suffer not an individual player or team, yes obviously because its Manchester United it will be in the headlines longer but who cares it benefited them and nobody should feel sorry for them

  2. Sam Peoples says:

    He didn’t send Shaun Derry off, the referee did. That was a bad dive from Young there, no denying that. The only reason that Drogba didn’t get anybody sent off is because he never had the chance to, how many players were yellow carded because of him?

    This is not an outcry of desperate need of sympathy as a United fan, far from it. It is a call for consistency to be applied to the whole concept of diving, irrelevant of the context that surrounds it or what team is involved.

  3. great article, although i dont condone Ashley for what he did, im getting fed up of the biased press and fans that seem to forget their own players behaviour…especially liverpool fans….

  4. Sam Peoples says:

    Cheers mate. The only thing I want is consistency, then controversy wouldn’t exist!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: